Our Staff First Federal of Van Wert

We will be CLOSED on Monday, January 19, 2026 in observance of the Martin Luther King, Jr., Day Holiday.

During this time you are welcome to access our ATMs, also online & mobile banking 24/7. Thank you!

NORTH TEAM – 820 N. Washington St.

Electronic mail (Email) is not secure and not confidential. Personal information should not be communicated in this manner.

First Federal of Van Wert, orange and teal, swipe artwork

Ashley Metzger

Branch Manager
NMLS #1655404

Erin McMillen
Assistant Branch Manager, NMLS #1159181, First Federal of Van Wert

Erin McMillen

Assistant Branch Manager
NMLS #1159181

CUSTOMER SERVICE TEAM

Cameron Keith, ITM Specialist, First Federal of Van Wert

Cameron Keith

ITM Specialist

Rachel Schaffner, Customer Service Representative, First Federal of Van Wert

Rachel Schaffner

Brianne Drake, Customer Service Representative, First Federal of Van Wert

Brianne Drake

Sydney King

COMMERCIAL TEAM

Thad Eikenbary, VP Commercial Lending NMLS #2140574, First Federal of Van Wert

Thad Eikenbary

VP Commercial Lending
NMLS #2140574

Shannon Greve, Commercial Relationship Specialist, First Federal of Van Wert

Shannon Greve

Commercial Relationship Specialist

FOX RD. TEAM – 679 Fox Rd.

Electronic mail (Email) is not secure and not confidential. Personal information should not be communicated in this manner.

First Federal of Van Wert, orange and teal, swipe artwork

Lisa Lawson, VP of Customer Experience at First Federal of Van Wert

Lisa Lawson

VP of Customer Experience

CUSTOMER SERVICE TEAM

Carly Rollins, Customer Service Manager of First Federal of Van Wert

Carly Rollins

Customer Service Manager

Brooke McMonigal, Customer Service Representative of First Federal of Van Wert

Brooke McMonigal

Allison Hauter, New Accounts Specialist, First Federal of Van Wert

Allison Hauter

New Accounts Specialist

Nikki Harris, Customer Service Representative, First Federal of Van Wert

Nikki Harris

Prima Hertel, Customer Service Representative, First Federal of Van Wert

Prima Hertel

Haylie Farmer, Customer Service Representative for First Federal of Van Wert

Haylie Farmer

of First Federal of Van Wert

Becca Haver

Angelus Haller, Customer Service Representative for First Federal of Van Wert

Angelus Haller

LOAN TEAM

Adam Ries, VP of Lending NMLS #1673167, First Federal of Van Wert

Adam Ries

VP of Lending
NMLS #1673167

Jen Klinker, Loan Operations Lead, First Federal of Van Wert

Jen Klinker

Loan Operations Lead

Rhonda Belt, Assistant Vice President-Residential Lending, NMLS #470189, First Federal of Van Wert

Rhonda Belt

AVP – Residential Lending
NMLS #470189

Ciara Thomas, Loan Processor, First Federal of Van Wert

Ciara Thomas

Loan Processor

Sheila Tumbusch, First Federal of Van Wert SR Mortgage Loan Officer, NMLS #896476

Sheila Tumbusch

SR Mortgage Loan Officer
NMLS #896476

Amber Cowan, Loan Processor, First Federal of Van Wert

Amber Cowan

Loan Processor

Stephanie Phillips, Branch Manager NMLS #1888107, First Federal of Van Wert

Stephanie Phillips

Loan Officer/Lending Manager
NMLS #1888107

Ashley Moyer

Loan Operations

OPERATIONS

Diana Cearns, VP of Operations / BSA Officer of First Federal of Van Wert

Diana Cearns

VP of Operations / BSA Officer

Debbie Bragg, Call Center Specialist, First Federal of Van Wert

Debbie Bragg

Call Center Specialist

of First Federal of Van Wert

Ruth Schutz, NCP

Sr Operations Analyst

Sherri Tindall, Call Center Specialist, First Federal of Van Wert

Sheri Tindall

Call Center Specialist

Scott Baber, Operations Specialist, First Federal of Van Wert

Scott Baber

Operations Specialist

Kindall Maxson, Universal Banker, First Federal of Van Wert

Kindall Maxson

Universal Banker

ADMINISTRATIVE

Brian R. Renner, President/C.E.O. First Federal of Van Wert

Brian Renner

President/C.E.O.

Ty Coil, Marketing Coordinator, First Federal of Van Wert

Ty Coil

Marketing Coordinator

Suzie Grimes, Chief Financial Officer, First Federal of Van Wert

Suzie Grimes

Chief Financial Officer

Terra Bonifas, Chief Administrative Officer NMLS #1506609, First Federal of Van Wert

Terra Bonifas

Chief Administrative Officer
NMLS #1506609

Amanda Schulte, Controller, First Federal of Van Wert

Amanda Schulte

Controller

Electronic mail (Email) is not secure and not confidential. Personal information should not be communicated in this manner.